Being that I cannot afford a big layout of cash for a super-smoker right now, I've been looking around at the 22.5 WSM's... really nice units, butt one thing concerns me. The aluminum door/access panel. They seem awfully flimsy for an almost $400.00 smoker.

I stopped at a local hardware on the way home today, and saw one on display where the door was all warped and didn't fit well at all. Is this a common problem with these, or...??? Mind you, this one had not seen any heat yet, and there was already a nasty gap at the top of the door. It could have been a shipping thing, or maybe the trunk monkey that assembled it screwed it up. Anyway, it has me concerned.

Anything I should be aware of?

Also, how accurate/dependable are the stock thermos that come with these buggers? In my past experience with stock units (on other brands), they were crap at best.

Thanks for your thyme! :thumb:

I looked & thought about one.....price sux. Decided to go for a UDS, got less than 70 bux in it & that's including the beer~!

I have an 18.5", and the access door should fit tight, it isnt a real heavy gauge, but it is ok. During the winter I have mine on the unit upside down to help with airflow.

The stock therm is accurate for the lid temp. My top grate is about 15 degrees hotter than the lid typically so I run my WSM @ 210-215 on the lid therm.. Once you get used to how the WSM cooks you really dont need thermometers everywhere imho. I just run it, close down the bottom vents as I need to, and let it do its magic. Also from experience you can pretty much tell how hot it is running by putting your hand over the top vent and feel how warm the air is coming out of the smoker.

WSM is a great unit, I have said it before, I gave away or sold all my other smokers when I got it.

good luck with your purchasing decision.

I looked & thought about one.....price sux. Decided to go for a UDS, got less than 70 bux in it & that's including the beer~!

:bounce: Yeah, I hear ya'. I'm getting closer and closer to building one... problem is, comp season is upon me, and I have other projects ahead of a UDS build... what's a Pop-Pop 2doo... :eek: :noidea:

I have the standard, and altho I like it, I would have never got one new. I paid like $30 at a garage sale.

I have the standard, and altho I like it, I would have never got one new. I paid like $30 at a garage sale.

Now for $30, I would not even hesitate! :thumb: When you say standard, is that the 18"er?

I haved used a 22.5 alot phil....I smoke my chipotles on one and have done SIX- 8-10 pound butts at one time....

I always turn the doors upside down,but after camping with my 18 inch i have used a rubber mallet to shape to fit....I have a 10 year old 18 WSM that the door fits not airtight and never effected my steady temps much....Some folks seal the door entirely,but i have never found this necessary....

I always use a probe at grate level and they make gromets that fit in side(that hold grates) ,so you dont crimp your wires...

The 22.5 can be a fuel hog if not doing big smokes....The 18 inchers are very efficent for littler smokes....

All the WSM are minnion machines...Put a stoker on one and they are fantastic...If i make the salisbury comp i will bring one with me....

I have found the smaller models cheap on e-bay etc....

Now for $30, I would not even hesitate! :thumb: When you say standard, is that the 18"er?

Yep... it's a bit small, tho... I'd pay more for a 22 for sure, but not new price.

Yep... it's a bit small, tho... I'd pay more for a 22 for sure, but not new price.

I agree....We got the 22.5 at 300 with shipping and i didnt pay for it...:thumb:

Usefull though for large batches( catering and smoking peppers etc)...They last forever...

I'll tell ya', after looking at the WSM's close up, the Smoke-EZ contraption I have is still a damn good deal... like a third of the cost and the same idea. It is 22.5", has two racks, no aluminum door, and sits atop a weber kettle grill. I have gotten as long as a six hour burn out of it (loaded with butts and ribs).

Maybe I'm just getting too anxious, or the looming tax refund is burning a hole in my cranium... :eek:

I have to stop confusing me. :bounce:

I'll tell ya', after looking at the WSM's close up, the Smoke-EZ contraption I have is still a damn good deal... like a third of the cost and the same idea. It is 22.5", has two racks, no aluminum door, and sits atop a weber kettle grill. I have gotten as long as a six hour burn out of it (loaded with butts and ribs).

Maybe I'm just getting too anxious, or the looming tax refund is burning a hole in my cranium... :eek:

I have to stop confusing me. :bounce:


I have run a 22.5 14 plus hours at steady temps on a minnion though...I use a UDS style basket in both....

I can bring a 18 incher to salisbury....I call it my chicken ching machine at comps.....The WSM have to be used to appreciate....They do appear pretty flimsy till used right and the consistent product you can turn out...

:bounce: what's a Pop-Pop 2doo... :eek: :noidea:
Make mo WIBS

I have run a 22.5 14 plus hours at steady temps on a minnion though...I use a UDS style basket in both....

I can bring a 18 incher to salisbury....I call it my chicken ching machine at comps.....

Cool! 14 hours? Holy crap!

Right now, I don't use a basket in the Weber/Smoke-EZ, butt I thought about it. I have been laying the coals in an arc around the outer diameter of the coal grate, and starting one end. It travels nicely around the perimeter, at a fairly slow rate.

Cool! 14 hours? Holy crap!

Right now, I don't use a basket in the Weber/Smoke-EZ, butt I thought about it. I have been laying the coals in an arc around the outer diameter of the coal grate, and starting one end. It travels nicely around the perimeter, at a fairly slow rate.


Cool thing about the 22.5 WSM is the rottisorie i bought for my kettle fits(with the extender ring) on the 22.5...You can smoke or grill and rotis a huge hunk a meat or buy any other rotis system that fits these rigs...I have done my thanksgiving birds last 10 years on my 18 incher with no water and open vents...2 and 1/2 funnels charcoal runs 350-320 degree 5-6 hours...they make great smoker ovens too...

The WSM have to be used to appreciate....\...



+1, I get 9-10 hours easy out of mine on one ring of lump, even in sub zero temps.

great smoker

You know what I'll say Phil:lol: the thin door fits nicley on mine have had no problems at all.I did find but didnt buy a stainless replacement door but havent needed it.and I believe you can find the 22.5 for under 400 bucks now.heres a fourum sight I havent joined but keep close tabs on .they have some good goings on over there.http://www.virtualweberbullet.com/ like I said before I love mywsm:bounce:http://www.aimtofind.com/weber-22-5-inch-smokey-mountain-cooker-pn-731001-2009-model.html?a_bid=bizrate&a_bid=0eafda91&gdftrk=gdfV21157_a_7c375_a_7c1051_a_7c731001
you can get this one with free shippingfor 387

You know what I'll say Phil:lol: the thin door fits nicley on mine have had no problems at all.I did find but didnt buy a stainless replacement door but havent needed it.and I believe you can find the 22.5 for under 400 bucks now.heres a fourum sight I havent joined but keep close tabs on .they have some good goings on over there.http://www.virtualweberbullet.com/ like I said before I love mywsm:bounce:http://www.aimtofind.com/weber-22-5-inch-smokey-mountain-cooker-pn-731001-2009-model.html?a_bid=bizrate&a_bid=0eafda91&gdftrk=gdfV21157_a_7c375_a_7c1051_a_7c731001
you can get this one with free shippingfor 387

Thanks for the links Bill. Yeah, I saw the "aimtofind" site when I did a search on Pricegrabber. It don't look like they're gonna get any cheaper... :eek:

heres a fourum sight I havent joined but keep close tabs on .they have some good goings on over there.http://www.virtualweberbullet.com/



good call on the VWB site, I belong over there and really like it. Tons of info on the WSM, plus the amazon link to buy the WSM.

I use the 22.5 alot and it works wonderfull! I also use a drum too, and it's hard to pick one over the other......if you don't include cost. For cost purposes....a drum is the way to go. You can do a drum in a couple of hours. I also use a guru and it makes the drum and wsm work even better.

I think I see Pop Pop's refund slowly dissapearing!:whistle:


If it makes you feel any better , I wish I had a 22.5 WSM.:Cry:

I think I see Pop Pop's refund slowly dissapearing! :whistle:

If it makes you feel any better , I wish I had a 22.5 WSM.:Cry:

Yes you do Dan, and all too quickly! I have to keep Mom-Mom happy first, then IF there's anything left... we'll see... :eek: