Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Salmon throwdown #2 - Mad Hunky vs Me

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Salmon throwdown #2 - Mad Hunky vs Me

    In the vein of BBQ Engineer's salmon brine throwdown thread I submit my own throwdown. Sorry not much in the way of pictures though.

    I've had a couple fillets of sockeye in the freezer for a couple months now, since about the same time as Rich announced the Mad Hunky Salmon Brine, which I of course had purchased as soon as it became available. I haven't had much time to work on these kind of things lately, but this weekend the stars aligned just right and allowed me to do this.

    So, I set up to do a taste test between the Mad Hunky brine and mine. Now for a little background smoked salmon is pretty common around here, since the days of native americans who'd dip net salmon from the local rivers and preserve them with smoke and fire. When you say 'smoked salmon' here what comes to mind is pretty much salmon jerky, or salmon candy if you will. It tends to run on the sweeter side, though not always. However if you buy store bought stuff around here more often than not it will have some sweetness to it. In that vein my standard brine is 4 parts brown sugar to 1 part pickling salt (by volume) with some garlic thrown in for good measure. I think I have a thread on here about my method, I'll see if I can find it and spare you that read here. [Edit to add:] OK, so I guess I've never made a thread here, but there's one over on Taz's Foods of the World Forum if you want to see how I it.

    I followed the directions for the MH brine to the letter, except that I didn't quite get the 24-hour brine time it called for. Was more like 21 hours.

    Typically I don't use cure in my salmon, but just to try to keep a level playing field I did add 1 TBSP of tenderquick that was sprinkled over my salmon before being packed in the brine.

    When removed from the brine there were a couple differences. First, mine had pulled quite a bit of juice from the flesh, which is typical, but the MH brine hadn't. The flesh on mine was quite firm, but the MH was still pretty soft. Mine had it's typically deep red color, which is probably a combination of being more dehydrated, and the brown sugar on the surface. The MH was still fairly pale in comparison. Almost the same color it had gone into the brine as.

    Into the smoker they went. I had a tough time controlling the temps because the weather was all over the place. It'd be sunny for a while, then dumping buckets of snow and blustering winds. I even had to make a small wind-break from my garbage cans and a piece of plywood. I was aiming for around 150 in the smoker but it ended up anywhere between 120-ish and 177 was the highest I saw. Anyway they spent 8 hours over cherry and were not quite finished when I decided to pull them and put them in the convection oven at 160. After about 45 minutes in there they were up to 145 internal and done to my liking.

    Here's what they looked like after coming out of the oven. MH on top, mine on bottom.


    They were both pretty firm at this point, though the Mad Hunky had a little more give to it when pressed in the thicker parts. Mine seemed to have a slightly more oily surface which quite possibly is due to being more firm to start with and ending up more dried, causing the oil to come out more. The colors seem to have evened out as well.

    Now for the taste test!


    My impressions were that mine is definitely firmer and drier, jerky-esque if you will, where the MH is a little more moist and flakey. The MH is a little more fish-forward where the flavor of the fish comes through very nicely and compliments the spices from the brine very well. Mine is more on the sweet and salty side. You get a hit of sweet right off the start and then a nice salty/fishy finish. The MH has a bit of honey sweetness at first but it's on the subtle side, followed by the fish flavor with the herbs and spices. Overall it's very well balanced. I enjoyed them both very much, and I'm glad to have the Mad Hunky salmon brine in my arsenal. Once again, an outstanding product from the Mad Hunky.

    My lunch today consists of a piece of each type of salmon with some horseradish to go with them.
    Attached Files
    Last edited by PitRow; 07-07-2023, 11:34 AM.
    Mike
    Life In Pit Row

  • #2
    Looks Mighty Tasty from the Bear's Den!!

    I could handle a big plate O-That Real Easy!!

    Nice Job!!----

    Bear
    Vietnam Vet---9th Inf. Div. Mekong Delta (1969)
    Easy to follow Step By Steps: Pulled Cured Boston Butt Ham and Buckboard Bacon--Smoked Salmon-- Bacon-On-A-Stick--Bacon (Extra Smokey)--Boneless Cured & Smoked Pork Chops & CB--Canadian Bacon & Dried Beef--Ham Twins (Double Smoked)--Double Smoked Hams X 4--Bear Logs (All Beef--Unstuffed)--Smoked Bear Loaf (All Beef-Mild Hot)--Prime Rib (My Best ever)--Another Prime Rib--Chucky (Pulled Beef)--Twin Chuckies--Pork and Beef Spares--Rare Beef (for Sammies)--Raspberry Chiffon Pie---


    Mom & 4 Cub litter---Potter County, PA:

    Comment


    • #3
      Nice job with the comparison. Love me some smoked salmon, though mine is typically on the savory side rather than sweet as I don't typically brine the salmon. I am going to have to try brining and see how the flavors work out. Thanks for sharing this great bit of information.... on the to do list for sure!
      Smokem if you got em

      Yoder YS640
      Weber EP-310 Gasser Grill
      A-Maz-N-Pellet-Smoker (AMZNPS)
      A-Maz-N-Tube-Smoker (AMZNTS)
      Frogmats
      Maverick ET 732
      Super Fast Purple Thermopen


      Deano

      "May the thin blue smoke be with you"

      sigpic

      Comment


      • #4
        Nicely done Mike! Yes..”smoked salmon” differs widely depending on region and family practices. My stuff was not really influenced by any thing much... never was a smoked salmon fan until a few years ago, so I was limited in my experience. I just kinda f’d around until I got something I liked

        The cure DOES add a different flavor I think. Small but noticable. Plus it’s a built in safty factor should some folk want to cool/cold smoke. You can use mine with canning salt in the same proportions to the added TQ as well.

        Again..thanks for checking it out, I appreciate it!
        In God I trust- All others pay cash...
        Check out the Mad Hunky and products at https://madhunkymeats.com or https://www.facebook.com/MadHunkyMeats
        Lang 60D, The Beast, 18 and 22 WSM, Brinkmann Backroads trailer, Weber 22 Kettle, gutted MB burning watts

        Comment


        • #5
          Excellent test comparison, and they both look good to me.

          without question.
          Lang 36 Patio, a few Webers, 2 Eggs, plenty of gadgets and a MES 40 Gen 2.5 electric for bacon and sausage.
          My best asset however is the inspiration from the members on this forum.

          sigpic
          @SmokinJim52 on Twitter

          Comment


          • #6
            Good looking smoke!! for the effort and details!! very nice!
            Brian

            Certified Sausage & Pepper Head
            Yoder YS640
            Weber Genesis
            Weber 18.5" Kettle
            Weber Performer
            Misfit # 1899

            sigpic

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by SmokinOutBack View Post
              Excellent test comparison, and they both look good to me.

              without question.
              Originally posted by barkonbutts View Post
              Good looking smoke!! for the effort and details!! very nice!
              What these fine Gentlemen said
              sigpic

              Comment


              • #8
                Nicely done test comparison.

                Both looked very tasty.
                Jim

                Comment


                • #9
                  Very cool salmon throw down. They both look great! Here are some fishy

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I tried smoking salmon once...And felt like I wasted a lot of good salmon...

                    Looks like you know what's going on...Great post...
                    Craig
                    sigpic

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Great experiment! That salmon looks friggin' awesome!
                      BBQ Eng.

                      The "Cow Girls" were adopted from the shelter, and found on petfinder.com.
                      Adopt a homeless pet - http://www.petfinder.com
                      I built the Iron Maiden - Iron Maiden Smoker Build

                      Over 5000 unreadable posts...Photobucket can kiss my ass...they will never get a dime. I will not pay a ransom.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Great post! I love smoked salmon, and they both looked fabulous!


                        Drinks well with others



                        ~ P4 ~

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X